You are here

Are the health claims about apple cider vinegar true? – BBC News

Image copyright iStock

Apple cider vinegar is a conventional folk solution that has actually been around for lots of centuries. Is it helpful for our health, asks Michael Mosley.

Cider vinegar is made by blending chopped-up apples with water and sugar, then enabling the mix to ferment, turning a few of it into acetic acid.

Despite being acidic and certainly something of a gotten taste, in the last few years cider vinegar has actually ended up being exceptionally popular. Due to the fact that of claims that it can assist with whatever from weight problems to divide ends and arthritis, at least a part of that is.

But which, if any, of the lots of various health claims made on its behalf withstand clinical analysis? For Trust Me, I’m A Doctor we partnered with Dr James Brown from Aston University to learn.

Find out more

Michael Mosley (left, above, with Dr James Brown) provides Trust Me, I’m A Doctor which returns for a brand-new series on Thursday 1 September on BBC Two at 20:00 BST – capture up on BBC iPlayer

We began by evaluating a claim which does appear to have the most clinical reliability – the claim that consuming a few tablespoons of vinegar, watered down in water, prior to a meal will assist you manage your blood glucose levels.

To see if there was compound to this concept we hired healthy volunteers and inquired to consume 2 bagels, after having actually fasted over night. We determined their blood glucose levels prior to and after consuming and, as we anticipated, bagel usage was followed by a fast and big increase in their blood sugar level levels.

The next day we asked to take in another 2 bagels, however this time we inquired to knock back a watered down shot of apple cider vinegar prior to doing so. We duplicated the test a couple of days later on, however this time we got our brave volunteers to gulp down some water down malt vinegar prior to the bagel.

It ended up that the cider vinegar, however not the malt vinegar, had a huge effect, lowering the quantity of sugar in the volunteers’ blood by 36% over 90 minutes.

Image caption Drinking water down apple cider vinegar appeared to bring blood sugar level levels down

This might be since the acetic acid in the cider vinegar reduces the breakdown of starches, which indicates that if you consume it prior to a carb-rich meal, less sugar will get soaked up. We anticipated the malt vinegar to have a comparable impact to the cider vinegar, however in our little research study it didn’t.

Next, we wished to see whether cider vinegar measured up to claims that it aids with weight reduction, decreases cholesterol and decreases swelling (which may assist with conditions like rheumatoid/inflammatory arthritis and eczema).

We hired 30 volunteers and divided them into 3 groups. Our very first group were asked to consume 2 tablespoons of cider vinegar watered down in 200ml of water two times a day, every day, prior to a meal. The 2nd group were asked to do the very same with malt vinegar and the last group were offered a placebo including coloured water.

Image caption Volunteers were divided into 3 groups

Two months later on I met Dr Brown and our volunteers to learn how they had all got on. A lot of were really favorable about the experience. A couple of idea they may have lost a little weight, with one stating she didn’t feel as much yearning for sweet things. Another volunteer with moderate arthritis informed me: “I have actually had less pains and discomforts in my joints, specifically after workout.” Another believed it had actually enhanced her eczema.

But exactly what did Dr Brown’s tests expose?

“I’m sorry to state,” he informed his expectant audience, “that none of you lost any weight.”

That was frustrating, though not completely unexpected.

So exactly what about the supposed anti-inflammatory residential or commercial properties of vinegar, which could discuss enhancements in arthritis or eczema? As part of the screening Dr Brown had actually determined our volunteers’ blood levels of something called C-reactive protein (CRP), a marker for swelling in the body.

Image caption Dr Brown (left) took blood samples as part of the experiment

Again, sadly, we didn’t see any modifications. We did see a little fall in the CRP levels of a few of those taking cider vinegar, however it wasn’t enough to obtain thrilled about.

So far things had actually been rather frustrating for vinegar drinkers. Dr Brown, nevertheless, had the outcomes for one last test to expose – the result on blood fats.

In neither the malt nor the placebo vinegar group existed any modification. Those taking in cider vinegar saw a typical 13% decrease in overall cholesterol, with a noticeably big decrease in triglycerides (a type of fat). And this was an especially remarkable finding due to the fact that our volunteers were all healthy at the start, with regular cholesterol levels.

“Bringing cholesterol levels down like this”, Dr Brown informed me, “can substantially lower your opportunities of having a cardiovascular disease in the future. We were actually delighted to see that finding.”

Image copyright iStock

So cider vinegar most likely will not assist anybody lose weight, however it might assist those who battle with their blood sugar level or cholesterol levels. Due to the fact that it is acidic I would just consume it watered down or utilize it moderately in food.

Michael Mosley provides a brand-new series of “Trust Me I’m a Doctor” which begins on BBC Two on Thursday 1 September at 20:00 BST

Follow @BBCNewsMagazine on Twitter and on Facebook

Read more: